Apple's AirPods have become a staple for many iPhone users since their introduction, thanks to their seamless integration within Apple's ecosystem and the innovative features they offer. As a senior reviewer at The Verge since its inception in 2011, my experience encompasses various audio devices, including smartphones, audio systems, and photography gear. In this article, we will explore the different models of AirPods available and help you decide which one might be the best fit for your needs.

When it comes to choosing a pair of AirPods, the selection can feel overwhelming. Apple offers four distinct models: the AirPods 4, AirPods 4 with active noise cancellation, AirPods Pro, and AirPods Max. Understanding the differences between these models is crucial, especially considering your personal preferences for design and functionality.

The Best AirPods Overall

If you are looking for the most feature-rich earbuds in the Apple lineup, the second-generation AirPods Pro should be your primary choice. They not only boast access to the latest software advancements from Apple but also include exclusive features that enhance their usability. For instance, if you frequently misplace your earbuds, you will appreciate the integrated U1 chip in the charging case, which allows you to utilize Apples Find My app for precise location tracking. This feature ensures that if you ever lose them, you can easily pinpoint their location with a few taps on your device.

The AirPods Pro are also renowned for their effective noise cancellation capabilities, which can significantly reduce ambient sounds in most environments, making your listening experience much more enjoyable. The sound quality is notably superior to that of the regular AirPods, aided by the silicone ear tips that create a secure in-ear seal.

In 2024, Apple introduced groundbreaking hearing health features, including an on-the-spot hearing test, automatic hearing protection, and the ability to use the AirPods Pro as clinical-grade hearing aids for individuals with mild to moderate hearing loss. This functionality distinguishes the AirPods Pro from other models in the lineup, including the AirPods Max. Furthermore, the Pro version includes innovative volume controls that allow users to adjust sound levels by simply swiping on the earbuds' stems, a nifty feature not found on the AirPods 4.

For Those Who Prefer an Open Design

Not everyone feels comfortable with in-ear tips, and for those individuals, Apple offers the standard AirPods 4. These earbuds feature a one-size-fits-most design that provides an open listening experience, which means users can remain aware of their surroundings. While the AirPods Pro does come with an impressive transparency mode, the AirPods 4 inherently allow outside sounds to filter in.

Apple markets two versions of the AirPods 4. Both models deliver excellent sound quality and microphone performance for voice calls, along with an IP54 rating for water resistancean important consideration for active users. The more expensive variant includes active noise cancellation and a sophisticated charging case, featuring wireless charging and Find My integration. You might be surprised to learn that even without a sealed design, the noise cancellation effectively dampens ambient noise, though louder sounds can still be heard.

If noise-canceling capability is a priority for you, I recommend investing a bit more in the AirPods Pro 2. They offer superior audio quality, enhanced noise cancellation, and an overall better listening experience compared to the noise-canceling AirPods 4.

The Best for Headphone Enthusiasts

For those who prefer over-ear headphones, the AirPods Max might be the ideal choice, albeit at a premium price point of $549. Over the years, I have fluctuated in my recommendations of these headphones, and while they feature a standout aesthetic and luxurious feel, the weight can become uncomfortable during prolonged use. However, Apple has made smart design decisions, such as utilizing breathable fabric ear cups that are much more comfortable in warm weather compared to the pleather found on many competitors' models.

The AirPods Max are lauded for their exceptional noise cancellation capabilities, and their transparency mode is considered the best in its class, delivering a clear and natural listening experience. When it comes to sound quality, these headphones boast a pleasing sound signature that remains enjoyable across various music genres, augmented by an impressive soundstage typical of closed-back designs.

Its important to note that the AirPods Max sacrifices some features like conversation awareness and adaptive audio, as they operate on Apples older H1 chip. Nonetheless, Apple has recently introduced support for lossless audio over USB-C, making these headphones capable of delivering the richest audio fidelity among the entire AirPods lineup.