This story is available exclusively to Business Insider subscribers. Become an Insider and start reading now.

The highly anticipated film, A Minecraft Movie, inspired by the iconic video game that ranks as the second best-selling title of all time, just behind Tetris, is set to hit theaters on Friday. As the release date approaches, critics have offered a wide array of reviews, ranging from scathing critiques to surprisingly positive remarks.

Despite the mixed feedback, industry experts believe that moviegoers will likely flock to cinemas. As noted by Business Insider, Minecraft joins a growing list of video game adaptations making their way onto the big screen. Historically, films like 2005’s Doom and 1993’s Super Mario Bros. struggled to achieve commercial success and were met with critical disdain. However, more recent adaptations have proven to be financially rewarding, paving the way for renewed interest in this genre.

Notably, the Super Mario Bros. movie released in 2023 shattered records, grossing over a billion dollars at the box office despite receiving negative reviews. Similarly, the HBO adaptation of The Last Of Us captured audiences' hearts, earning eight Emmy Awards this year. These successes showcase that video game adaptations can resonate with viewers, even in a challenging cinematic landscape.

Critics have not held back their opinions on A Minecraft Movie, which stars prominent actors Jack Black and Jason Momoa. The storyline revolves around a group of adults and children who find themselves transported through a portal into the vibrant world of Minecraft, where they must navigate various challenges to return home. While some reviewers have commended Momoa’s performance and highlighted the film’s fun and comedic moments, others have deemed it generic and uninspiring.

The Daily Beast's Nich Schager did not mince words, labeling the film as “an absolute disaster even gaming fans will hate.” Similarly, a review from Jasmine Valentine of Dexerto went viral for describing it as “the worst film of the year,” advising fans of the game to stick to their consoles rather than spending money on the film.

In spite of these reviews, Deadline and Variety reported this week that box office tracking services predict A Minecraft Movie could gross between $130 million to $150 million globally during its opening weekend. Notably, the film's production budget stands at $150 million, which makes its box office performance critical to its success.

If the projections hold true, A Minecraft Movie could achieve the status of the second-highest-grossing debut for a Western film in 2025, although it’s essential to consider that the box office performance this year has been lackluster overall.

Rob Mitchell, director of theatrical insights at Gower Street Analytics, explained that the film occupies a unique niche, appealing to both parents familiar with the Minecraft franchise and children who are drawn to its colorful and engaging world. He stated, “It’s a film older generations might know the IP of, but that is suitable and fun for kids. It has 'family audience' appeal because everyone can go.” The timing of the release is also strategic, coinciding with the start of the Easter holidays in several countries, allowing families to take advantage of their time off.

Jezz Vernon, a film producer based in London and a senior lecturer in film and industry studies at the University of Exeter in the UK, echoed this sentiment. He suggested that parents are on the lookout for “cost-effective” entertainment options for their children, especially during school breaks. Additionally, Vernon noted that the character played by Jason Momoa is designed with an aesthetic reminiscent of the 1980s, which may resonate as a nostalgic nod for adult audiences while potentially flying over the heads of younger viewers.

Despite the polarized reception from critics, it appears unlikely that these reviews will significantly impact the film's box office performance. Vernon emphasized that “electronic word of mouth” often plays a crucial role in determining the success of a film after its debut, especially in instigating sequels. Mitchell also pointed out that gamers are likely to base their decisions on marketing efforts rather than critical reviews, suggesting a significant potential audience still remains.

What could pose a risk, however, is the reaction from general audiences. A negative response from everyday viewers could lead to a sharp decline in ticket sales following the opening weekend. As Vernon stated, “While marketing can help build the initial opening weekend, the longer-term success of a film heavily relies on word of mouth.”

Negative reviews can certainly correlate with a film's failure at the box office, as seen with Disney’s recent Snow White remake, which has struggled to break even following its premiere last month. However, as Mitchell pointed out, Snow White faced numerous controversies that likely diminished its appeal, and its source material is considerably older and less connected to today’s younger generation compared to the universally recognized Minecraft.

Although critics may not unanimously praise A Minecraft Movie, it could very well serve as a boost for the film industry as it gears up for the summer blockbuster season.