This article contains spoilers through the Season 3 finale of The White Lotus.

The guests arriving at White Lotus resorts embark on their journeys via boat, a detail that has taken on a deeper, almost mythological significance in the context of the series. These guests are not merely going on vacation; they are entering a surreal, magical-realist realm where they confront various manifestations of fate, pride, vanity, and greed. This journey is akin to a rite of passage, characterized by the juxtaposition of luxurious poolside drinks and lavish breakfast buffets. The high-stakes narrative is further enhanced by elements of absurd humor. As I watched the gripping finale of Season 3, I found myself questioning the fate of Timothy Ratliff, played by Jason Isaacs. Would he really resort to murdering his entire family, using pia coladas as his weapon of choice? This intriguing dilemma showcased the show's darkly comedic undertones against its more serious themes.

Tim Ratliff's storyline is arguably the darkest the HBO series has offered to date, delving into the harrowing, suicidal fantasies of a man teetering on the brink of despair. From the moment he arrived at the White Lotus in Thailand, everything spiraled downward. He learned that his relationship with a business associate was under investigation for financial misdeeds, and by the third episode, the FBI had raided his office. His once-thriving world crumbled before him as panicked employees flooded his phone with desperate calls. The fear of being outed as a failure to his family drove Tim to confiscate their devices and indulge in his wife's stash of lorazepam. The psychological toll became evident as he transformed into a haunted figure, plagued by visions of violence against his loved ones.

Read: The rich tourists who want more, and more, and more

The White Lotus serves as a sharp social satire, and during discussions among my colleagues on Slack, some argued that Tim's final speech to his family was reminiscent of the absurd humor found in Arrested Development. However, I found the scene unsettling rather than humorous, and I suspect that was the intended effect. Over the course of three seasons, the show has dissected the multifaceted nature of toxic masculinity. In Season 1, Shane, played by Jake Lacy, embodied a catastrophic sense of entitlement, while Mark, portrayed by Steve Zahn, grappled with feelings of inadequacy within his marriage and concerns about his health. Season 2 introduced Albie (Adam DiMarco), who condemned the outdated sexism of his father and grandfather, alongside Cameron (Theo James), who engaged in infidelity and exploitation. Yet, none of these story arcs carried the grave implications or the stark realism presented in Tim's narrative, which highlighted the potential for even an ostensibly devoted family man to become a murderer.

Familicide, the act of killing ones children and often one's spouse or partner, is a disturbing phenomenon that occurs with alarming frequency in the United Statesapproximately every five days. A 2013 study categorized those who commit familicide into four distinct groups: anomic, disappointed, self-righteous, and paranoid. Tim Ratliff falls squarely into the anomic category, where individuals perceive their families as extensions of their success and status. When confronted with the loss of that status, they often cannot conceive of their families thriving independently. It is significant to note that the overwhelming majority of familicide perpetrators are men, most of whom do not fit a traditional criminal profile. David Wilson, a criminologist, noted in a Wired article that these family annihilators generally maintain a facade of being loving husbands and devoted fathers, often holding prominent jobs and appearing outwardly successful. Many of them become dangerously unstable when faced with financial ruin, and Wilson posited that the impulse for such extreme violence is deeply intertwined with the notion of masculinity in crisis. Men like Tim may feel emasculated by their failures, unable to envision a future where their loved ones continue without them.

Throughout the season, Tim has loomed over The White Lotus like a heavy, ominous cloud, with Jason Isaacs delivering a stellar performance. However, the complexity of Tim's defeatism left me questioning how we are meant to interpret his character. In a pivotal moment in the finale, Tim watches his wife embrace their daughter, visibly relieved that her spoiled nature prevents her from committing to a Buddhist retreat. His slight eyebrow raise and baffled expression might suggest that he is wrestling with the dark thought of needing to eliminate them both. When he tells his younger son, Its your last day. Dont just sit in here, is Isaacs hinting at a darkly comedic twist? Tim's chilling monologue over the toxic cocktails he prepares for his familyI couldnt ask for a more perfect family. Weve had a perfect life, havent we? No privations, no suffering, no trauma. And my job is to keep all that from you. To keep you safe. I love you. I love you so muchserves as a haunting thesis statement for a man who seems prepared to choose death over the potential tarnishing of his familys perception of him.

This is undeniably dark material for mainstream television. Throughout the season, show creator Mike White has masterfully built tension around Tims violent impulses, illustrating his fantasies in graphic detail. Tim sought various methods of committing murder-suicide, initially stealing a gun and later inquiring about the dangerous suicide tree from Pam, an oddly candid hotel employee. At one point, he even went so far as to harvest poisonous seeds, grind them, and prepare drinks for his wife and children, only to have a moment of clarity and discard the drink from his elder sons hand. The scene where his younger son, who collapses after consuming a protein smoothie made from the same toxic blender, awakens in his fathers arms, leaves us questioning whether this moment is meant to signify redemption for Tim. Has he undergone a transformation that will enable him to confront his family with the harrowing truth of what he almost did? The series leaves that question lingering, never providing a resolution.

Read: The White Lotus doesnt stick the landing

The closing moments of Season 3where the narrative shifts away from the Ratliffs just as they confront the reality of their financial collapse and their fathers probable imprisonmentleft me feeling more unsettled than Tims violent fantasies. For weeks, The White Lotus toyed with a macabre storyline, deftly entwining suspense and dramatic potential. If Tim had actually acted on his impulses and harmed a loved one, it would have marked a significant shift in the shows narrative direction, indicating a willingness to explore the darkest corners of human nature and karmic outcomes. Perhaps HBO executives stepped in to suggest that family annihilation was too dark for a satirical comedy. Nevertheless, the decision to explore such a fraught topic, only to retreat at the last moment, feels disingenuous. It leaves us grappling with the unsettling implications of Tims arc as just another tale of tragic enlightenment.