The world of cocoa has experienced a dramatic rollercoaster ride recently, with fluctuations in prices creating a landscape that is as unpredictable as it is fascinating. As Easter approaches, the demand for chocolate egg treats remains high, yet the cocoa markets have shown signs of volatility that would put even the most seasoned investors on alert. In 2024, cocoa prices nearly tripled, astonishingly outperforming even the cryptocurrency sensation Bitcoin during that period. However, this meteoric rise was followed by a significant downturn in February, leaving many to question the sustainability of such price trends.

Typically, cocoa is classified as an inelastic commodity; this means consumers tend to continue purchasing it despite rising costs. However, the cocoa market is currently facing serious challenges, as three consecutive years of poor harvests begin to take their toll. Analysts are increasingly concerned, with some revising down their forecasts for iconic US confectioner Hershey, which is set to report its first-quarter earnings in just a couple of weeks. The stakes are high, and the implications of these forecasts could have a ripple effect throughout the confectionery industry.

What makes cocoa particularly unique compared to other cyclical commodities are the peculiar dynamics at play. Speculators significantly influence the market, leading to heightened volatility. Moreover, responding swiftly to price changes in cocoa is complicated by the growth cycle of the cocoa plant. It typically takes about four years for a cocoa tree to begin producing fruit, making it challenging for producers to react quickly to market fluctuations, unlike annual crops such as wheat or rye.

In the two West African nations of Ivory Coast and Ghana, which collectively account for nearly half of the world's cocoa production, the pricing system is heavily dominated by monopoly state buyers rather than the free market. This situation creates a scenario where a cocoa farmer in Ghana, for instance, might receive a fixed rate that is less than half of the prevailing market price. Consequently, these farmers are often reluctant to invest in necessary inputs such as pesticides or new trees, especially when prices for these essentials are soaring.

The cumulative effects of pests and adverse weather conditions have led to significant production deficits over the past three years. Alarmingly, in 2024, the production gap was reported to be one-tenth of the previous years output. A significant factor contributing to these shortfalls is the age of cocoa trees; many in the Ivory Coast are now estimated to be over 30 years old, which is past their optimal productive lifespan. Additionally, in response to the declining profitability of cocoa farming, some farmers have diverted their efforts to more lucrative ventures such as illegal gold mining and rubber plantations, allowing opportunistic profiteers to step in where traditional agricultural practices are waning.

Looking at the situation from a long-term perspectiveapproximately four years, which is the time needed for new cocoa saplings to mature and bear fruitthere is potential for the market to rebalance itself towards a surplus. Countries not bound by fixed pricing structures, such as Ecuador (the third-largest cocoa supplier) and several other emerging markets across Latin America and Africa, are expected to ramp up production. Additionally, a favorable turn in weather conditions could further augment yields, and better pest control could alleviate some of the diseases affecting the crops. The International Cocoa Organization has projected a modest surplus of around 3 percent of production for the current season, which may ease some of the current tensions in the market.

The inelastic nature of cocoa demand adds another layer of complexity. Factors such as tariffs, the growing popularity of weight-loss drugs, and food scientists experimenting with alternatives like shea butter, palm oil, and lab-created substitutes could influence future demand for traditional cocoa products. As consumers continue to enjoy their chocolate Easter eggs, those looking to invest in cocoa will need to brace themselves for a turbulent ride ahead.

For further insights and inquiries, please contact: louise.lucas@ft.com